This Seattle Times article had me irritated this morning. Here is an excerpt (in bold)
ALGIERS, Algeria — Now is not the right time for the U.S. to move forward on a once-celebrated deal for civilian nuclear cooperation with Russia, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said Saturday.
Her comment increased speculation that President Bush is planning to punish Moscow for invading Georgia, a former Soviet republic, by canceling the agreement. Such a move is being planned, but is not final, according to senior Bush administration officials.Here is my reaction:
This new intense stand-off with Russia is one of the most frustrating foreign policy developments I have seen come out of the Bush administration... and I've seen a lot of bad foreign policy from George W. Bush.
There is very little the United States can or should do about the tensions between Moscow and Georgia regarding the disputed territories. This is simply not a matter for the US to try to resolve. while Condoleezza Rice is talking about canceling nuclear energy agreements, the new lack of cooperation and new tensions will no doubt carry over into both countries nuclear arms decisions.
I don't like the rhetoric from Bush or John McCain stating that Russia is an enemy. This is simply not true. Is it 1980 again? Bush and McCain may not like Putin very much, and I'm sure the feeling is mutual. But we should not roll back agreements with whole nations just because we don't like their elected leaders. If other countries did this, we would probably not have any treaties or agreements with any other countries right now... given that most other nations approve of Bush less than the 31 % approval we at home give him.
We do not need a war or an new arms race with Russia. They don't want it, and neither should we.
Furthermore, we have completely dissipated our military might on other questionable foreign ventures, like the quest to eliminate the non-existent weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. And we have still not captured the terrorist that killed thousands right here at home seven years ago... wasn't Bush going to smoke him out of his cave, or something tough sounding like that?
Telling Russia that they have to get out of Georgia "or else" is a hollow threat that could very likely restart the Armageddon countdown. The cold war was NOT something we should restart, whether or not George Bush has friends in Georgia. It is simply too risky for humankind to even think about starting this up again.
We simply need to let Georgia and Russia work this out... even if they get involved in military movements. If things were reversed, and Alaska decided it wanted to be independent, would we allow Russia to tell us to leave them alone? I know it is not an exact parallel, but it is not too far off. Georgia was a USSR state for twenty years longer than Alaska has been a US state. And WE would NEVER let Russia tell us what to do. By the same token, Russia will not let George W Bush, or John McCain tell them what to do, no matter how tough they talk. Iraq is a small country (pop 27 million), with a small amount of technology and military might, compared to the force available in Russia (pop 143 million, nuclear arsenal).
Don't get me wrong. If Russia was in any way threatening the US right now, I would agree we should fight back hard; and make it clear that threats to our families and property would be met with overwhelming force.
But this is an argument with a disputed territory, on the other side of planet earth.
Time to stop making war... particularly when we can't get out of the ones we've already started.